Mascaras of 2008: 3-rating

We are at the mid-way point of the Mascaras of 2008! Think of 3-rated mascaras as the letter-C mark that you got on that midterm paper you did in high school or college. You remember….the one that you didn’t really put your ALL into. That’s how I feel about these mascaras here. They were just “eh”. Missing something. Lacking “umph”. And the funny thing is…you had high expectations getting a pretty decent grade. But…a C+? Ralphie knows what I’m talkin’ about.

Mascaras with a 3-rating by ClumpsOfMascara

Prescriptives Beyond Long
Bourjois Pump Up the Volume
CoverGirl Lash Exact
Napoleon Perdis Set
Max Factor 2000 Calorie
MAC Fibre Rich
L’Oreal Double Extension Beauty Tubes

I may get a lot of heat for that last one but I just wasn’t a huge fan of L’Oreal’s newest fiber mascara. Have you tried this one? What say you?

Stay beautiful,

(photo source)


    Ahhhh!!! I can’t believe that u rated Loreal Double Extension Beauty Tubes a 3?!! How dare you!!! J/K girl…keep ’em coming, I’m lovin’ these posts!!! But yeah… I’m a huge fan of that mascara, just b/c it’s mess free and it gave me pretty good length. My lashes are pitiful…LOL!!

  • Askmewhats

    ohhh I can’t wait to read more of your post til the year 3000!!! LOL Happy New Year girl!! !Stay pretty and positive love ya!

  • Bella

    I luvz 2000 calorie!!! It has woorked for me for ages – at a good price as well :0(

  • Smirking Cat

    2000 Calorie would be a good mascara if it didn’t flake all over the place!

  • Katee "e-polishblog"

    Happy New Year, B!!