Top Mascaras for Length & Volume!
Top Mascaras for Length & Volume

What clumped, what ran and what truly transformed our real-woman testers

We had 12 beauty-junkie members of our Total Beauty Squad test out so-called lengthening and volumizing mascaras. Their verdict: You could spend a fortune on the best — but you don’t have to. See what was tops.

Their findings

  • PBW

    I snatched up Stiletto mascara at Walmart last night! Thanks for her earlier review!

  • The Pretty Brown Girl

    I got that Neutrogena Healthy Volume in the mail yesterday and wore it out last night. I really do like it. Thanks for that recommendation, B!

  • Malca J

    I swear by L’oreal Voluminous!! My face just doesn’t look finished with my Voluminous lashes.

  • NaturallyAlise

    I copped the Stiletto too, and it is pretty dang-on awesome!

  • Erica

    Where is Smashbox’s Bionic mascara? That stuff is unreal!

  • Brigitte

    I agree, Smashbox’s Bionic mascara is absolutely amazing!!!