Mascaras of 2008: 5-rating

Mascaras with a 5-rating by ClumpsOfMascara

It’s my birthday! Happy birthday to meeee! I am still enjoying a little vacay in Atlanta but the mascara party must go on.

5-ratings mean that these mascaras by far are the BEST in my book. Notice that all but one of them are drugstore brands! Feel free to argue with me. Hate Imju Fiberwig? Think that Lash Stiletto is the pits? Tell me!!

Best in Length:
Imju Fiberwig
Maybelline XXL Extensions
Maybelline Lash Stiletto

Best in Curl:
Maybelline Curl Power

Best in Volume
Max Factor Volume Couture

Maybelline Great Lash
Neutrogena Healthy Volume

Stay beautiful,

  • *Jen*

    Happy New Year B!!! Wishing you much love and happiness in 2009!

  • Anjela

    Happy Birthday Brittany!!! I hope New Year’s Day was memorable for you! :)

  • Anonymous

    Happy Birthday!!! On the mascara note, I would have to disagree with Fibrewiig! It was a really good mascara except for the fact that I had to worse fallout ever and I am not talking about raccoon eyes. The fibres fell in my eyes all day and hurt! I’d give this a 4.

  • Izar

    Happy Birthday Brittany!!! 😀

    I wish you lots of love, success and happiness for 2009!


  • Askmewhats

    Oh mY!!!! Happy Happy Birthday B!!!! :) Have a great bday and great start of the year!!!!

  • Katee "e-polishblog"

    Happy new year and happy birthday, girlie!!


  • The Pretty Brown Girl

    Happy Birthday, Britt! Enjoy your special day.

  • juvenescent

    Happy birthday! I meant to Twit you last night at midnight when you were on.

    Thanks so much for the reviews, I can actually afford some of these. YAY!

  • Shefali

    Happy Birthday!!

    I’d have to strongly, strongly disagree with Maybelline Great Lash. I’d give that a zero – it’s the worst mascara I’ve ever tried. Absolutely no difference on my lashes, plus, the most horrible fallout ever! I threw it away after using it 3 times.

  • Kim @ A.L.O.S.

    Happy Birthday to a fellow Capricorn!!!!

  • Anonymous

    i looooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooove (LOVE!!) healthy volume! It has THE best wand and formula. I even like it better than lash blast.

    and i bought it all b/c of your review.

    thank you and happy birthday! =D

  • Sara

    hey i notice covergirl last blast isnt rated…why is that?

  • Toma

    Happy Birthday and Happy New Year!

  • Anonymous

    I’ve never understood why so many people like Great Lash. Maybe I’m missing something, but its just so so for me.

  • Blackberry Molasses/The Rebel Intellectual

    Happy birthday to ya!!

    Oh and NEWSFLASH!!!

    Walmart is doing a 2-for-1 on the Mabelline XXL line. 2 fab mascaras for the price of one!!! Stock up ladies!!!!

  • Mgnta

    I’m SO surprised that Maybelline’s Lash Stylish isn’t here. It is the best mascara that I have ever purchased. None of the high end brands could ever compare. You should definitely give this mascara a try!

  • Tashina

    I know I’m a little late but happy belated birthday.